Nonstop construction noise and dust
Pros
There is a great sense of community in the building, and the day-to-day building staff are also super friendly and have been here for years. The pre-war architecture is beautiful, and the original apartment layouts are spacious. The neighborhood can get busy with tourists, but it is the perfect location to access Central Park and most train lines.
Cons
The landlord is #88 of the 100 worst landlords in NYC according to the public advocate. A lot of the building infrastructure is in need of repair, but the owner has focused renovation efforts on demolishing pre-war apartments and making several smaller units in the same footprint. There is non-stop noise from construction, and the city has issued several violations for improper construction practices, including illegal asbestos removal and high levels of lead dust throughout the building. Both elevators keep breaking down, and water will be randomly turned off throughout the day. The owner has also been refusing to renew leases for current tenants and is generally slow to respond to complaints.
Gem of a Building
Pros
Awesome Super/doorman team. Really responsive to apartment concerns. Great mix of friendly neighbors, and always clean.
Cons
Someone reported us as an illegal AirBnB because we had family stay over two weekends in a row. There are some nosy neighbors, but they are few and far between.
Advice to the owners
Fix the water pressure on the upper floors. Sometimes it can completely stop mid-shower.